It’s one of the most argued questions among book lovers. Some people feel an audiobook is a shortcut, while others have listened to a hundred books and never doubted it. The honest answer is that for most books and most purposes, listening counts. There are a few places where reading on the page still does better, and knowing them helps you choose.
Reading and listening share most of the work that matters. You follow a plot, keep track of characters, picture the scenes, and think about the ideas. Research comparing the two for narrative books has generally found that people understand and remember them similarly when they’re paying attention. Decoding words on a page is only one part of reading, and for adult readers it isn’t the hard part.
Books also began as spoken things. Homer was recited. Dickens read his novels to packed halls. Many older books have a rhythm that comes alive when you hear them.
There are real differences, and they’re worth being honest about.
Listening has its own advantages too:
A reading goal is your own, and the point is usually to spend more time with books. Most people who track their reading count audiobooks. If you’d rather keep them separate, note which ones you listened to. Ways to read more books in a busy week.
Aloud is an iPhone and iPad app that reads books aloud, and it’s built for people who like to both listen and look. I make Aloud, so weigh that. You can follow the words as they’re read, change the speed at any point, and bookmark passages to find again.
It has free classics from Project Gutenberg and more than 20,000 LibriVox recordings read by volunteers. You can also open a DRM-free EPUB or PDF of your own from Files, and the first one is free. Aloud works offline once a book is on your phone, and your books are never uploaded.
Import a DRM-free EPUB, PDF or text file and listen to it in chapters. The voice is generated on your iPhone, and your first import is free.
No. Stories were told aloud long before most people could read, and listening still takes attention and imagination. If you followed the book and remember it, you've read it in any sense that matters.
For stories, studies tend to find similar understanding when people pay attention. For dense material, reading on a page can have the edge because it's easier to slow down and reread.
Yes. A reading goal is your own, and most people who track their reading include audiobooks.
Novels with a strong story, memoirs, and older books written with reading aloud in mind. Books built around tables, diagrams or footnotes are usually better on paper.